Continuing my profiles of questionable Philadelphia Marathon Results, I am shining the highlighting a runner that was previously mentioned as part of my initial article regarding Philadelphia back in December. She remains in the results. When I contacted the timer, he did not feel this evidence was conclusive. I disagree. I will be forwarding this information to the race director directly as this case is a bit more complicated than the obvious course cutters.
The splits alone are not enough to justify a disqualification. There was a fairly significant decrease in pace between the 10k and half, and then from the half to the finish. This is more pronounced than is typical for someone that runs a Boston Qualifying time, but not out of the realm of possibility.
Her previous PR was 4:10:41 in April of 2016. Her Philadelphia time is 3:21:47
She also has a recent 1 mile race that ws run in 6:56:00, slower than her Philadelphia Half Marathon pace.
To summarize what we have so far, she claims to have run a 50 minute PR as her 4th marathon in 2 months. The first half of that marathon was at a faster pace than she has run any other known race at any distance.
Note: The Boston Marathon entry was not earned through a qualifying time. There is no qualifying marathon.
Additional Philadelphia Evidence
The only photos of Noemi are near the finish line. She was not pictured on any other section of the course.
Once Again…Social Media Provides Evidence
This post was made at 7:13 AM. Her results show that she crossed the start line started at 7:04:34 AM. An argument *could* be made that there was a lag with Facebook uploading photos. After some started questioning her race, she deleted this post. Also, it appears to me that these photos were not taken from the start corral but among spectators.
The post above shows her intention to run Boston 2019. She also tagged a friend that ran The Philadelphia Marathon as well. In fact, according to the splits, they ran the first half together. All splits were identical or within 1 second of each other. However, they appear in no photos together. Also, she appears in no photos during the first half of the race.
There are photos of her racing partner on the course. She does not appear in any of those photos with him. Island Photos confirmed that they were unable to find any photos of the two runners together on the course. They have no photos of her on the first half of the course.
It is my opinion that her friend muled her bib for the first half (or more) of the race before handing it off to her. I believe the evidence here is conclusive.
To summarize the evidence:
- Personal Record during 4th marathon within 2 months. 1st Half split faster pace than any recorded splits at any distance
- Facebook post shown within crowd posted AFTER she should have started – post has been removed
- Running Partner has identical splits through 13.1 miles – they appear in no photos together
- She appears in no photos during the first half of the race
Thank you to all those that support the site. Contributions help cover costs associated with running MarathonInvestigation.com. If you support what we are doing, please consider a small contribution.
I don’t think the Facebook post can be considered as evidence. I had such lags too when posting Facebook pictures. Sometimes minutes, sometimes hours, totally unreliable — and so it’s not even relevant if she is in her corral on that photo or not.
The personal record is very suspicious, but maybe some where training marathons, maybe she was sick, who knows? No evidence.
That she didn’t qualifiy for her Boston debut… why does that matter?
The most suspicious is that she was not on the same pictures as her running partner… but all in all, how can you seriously expect a formal disqualifications based on a bunch of suspicions?
The timing of the post along with her deleting it are very suspicious.
The mention of Boston…to prevent people asking how she qualified.
No photos of her on the course and there are photos of her running partner. She is not in any of those photos.
Runners have been DQd for less.
It’s unlikely that she took the photo much before the time stamp (7:13 a.m.). Anyone who has run Philly knows how dark it is at the start. A quick Google search indicates that on November 19, 2017 sunrise was at 6:51 a.m. The photos of her, especially the three at the bottom, have enough light to suggest that it happened well after sunrise and probably right around the indicated time stamp.
The woman’s a cheater, plain and simple. If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.
Why are there no photos of her? If a photo is taken and a person isn’t on it, the only sane explanation is that the person wasn’t there.
I agree this seems very obvious to me what happened. Nice research. I’ve run Philly 6 times.
I think the most damning evidence is the deletion of the Facebook post.
Just check her NYRR races times. She would have to run all out to run a mile at this pace. Things people will do on social media to look extra special is amazing. She even brought God into it. LOL. I hope the God forgives her for her sins.
Comments are closed.